Monday, September 29, 2008

Failure!

I wanted to write about the blasts! I wanted to try and understand what all of you out there feel about this, no not the enraged version, but a lil sober, well thought out, articulate version. I read SMM about her reservations against Muslims and am well aware of the general mindset that prevails in India and condescending statements about how all Muslims are not terrorists, but all terrorists are Muslims, etc etc. 

But I decided to examine the plight of a regular, non fundamentalist, educated Muslim. Here is someone who knows since the tender age of 5 that when she's travelling in public transport, she has to travel under a false name, more importantly, a Hindu name.  She's accused of being a Pakistani, which at the age of 3 is akin to being called anti national. She's often advised, suggested, threatened to go back to her country (Pakistan and not India, since it is assumed that Muslims ought to be in Pakistan and Hindus alone should be in India). 

She went to one of the premier schools in the capital, went on to one of the prominent law schools in the country and when she needed to rent a place to stay in Delhi, she couldn't find one. Well that is until she assumed another false, Hindu name. 

As a youngster like one of us, she too enjoys the occasional party, but she's learnt to hold her identity close to her and it takes a while for her to let her guard drop and tell you her religion. If she'd ever tried keeping track of the number of times she's heard the lines "Oh, you dont look Muslim." (Like what is a Mussalman supposed to look like?) or "Really, you drink wine, isn't that anti islam?" or "Hey, I have a lotta Muslim friends." (and that makes you secular because...?????), she'd have aged centuries in a year. 

She hates how even the most educated, 'liberal', 'open minded' individuals end up differentiating on the basis of religion and how Prez. Mush. is called a liberal Mussalman only coz he enjoys his whiskey. She is appalled at how years of friendship, relationships and love are forgotten with each successive blast. She wonders how only the Muslims stand out as terrorists and the LTTE, Naxalites, ULFA and billion other organizations who run parallel governments now, are conveniently ignored since they aren't Muslim. 

As an educated minority within her own community, she has long accepted that she needs to be the voice of reason, she needs to speak out for her people who cannot articulate their thoughts, their fears, their insecurities. Like the rest of her countrymen, she too hated fundamentalists, of all religions and she completely denounced any acts of terror, carried out in the name of Allah. But of late she knew she'd have to come to terms with the facts that she was fighting a losing battle. 

She'd fallen in love with someone, he loved her too. But he was Hindu and she was Muslim. He could see beyond that, but both of them knew that their families would not. They tried for a while, but it was just too painful. Eventually, like every other privilege, he too was snatched away from her, for being Muslim. 

She had tried long and hard to be one of the regular, educated, cosmopolitan youths, but each look of suspicion, each denial of her right, each deeper scrutiny of her actions, was worrying her and she was learning to find safety in numbers. She now understood why her ilk sought refuge in ghettoes, where they'd be amongst their own, without being looked at accusingly or suspiciously. She knew she'd never become a fundamentalist, but she couldn't live like this either. That's when she knew she'd have to run away.

She systematically liquidated her assets, closed all accounts, put in her papers at work, served her notice period, sold her car, had one final party at her place where her closest friends still genuinely enjoyed her company and boarded her flight to her freedom.

Her name appeared a week later in the list of dead, after they found her body from under the rubble.  She now knew there was no escaping it. She had tried to run to the other end of the world, but somehow had managed to board that very flight that now symbolizes the very basis of what she wanted to escape. 


7 comments:

Akshaya Kamalnath said...

Running away is never the answer. And this is a brilliant post..it got me thinking about the plight of muslims who also think and feel for humanity and are not fundamentalist...reminded me of the movie Khuda ke liye..Anyway its great to have such voices speaking out.

Akshaya Kamalnath said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Utopia said...

sigh! what does one say to all of this and the rest which is yet to come. i dread to imagine!

She said...

@Akshaya: I know running away is not the answer, but do you think that one person, with ll her selfish desires and wants can actually change the system in one lifetime? So is it self preservation that makes one run away of plain selfishness?

@Utopia: The picture seems to be getting bleaker and bleaker, but all's not lost yet. There is hope yet woman.

Nautankey said...

Nice one.Probably because I am in the southern part I cant relate much to some pieces,like muslims not being given house for rent,may be it has started happening here too and I am not aware. I never had an argument about terrorism with my friends who are muslims,but now can imagine how their thought process would be.

But there is hope..lets try and keep that faint flickering candle on for as long as we can.

Anu said...

Its hard for smaller communities. I never realized being a hindu was so different till I landed in states, and my colleagues asked me about my gods with elephant on their heads.. good post.

SMM said...

She: Excellent post. I can feel her pain at being considered an alien in her own country.

I wrote what I felt straight from the heart. I don't think I'm secular because I have a Muslim and a Parsi friend, but because I was never taught to differentiate vbecause someone's name was Salma and not Sita. Unfortunately this is the situation today where we differentiate between Salma and Sita.But that's exactly what i'm saying. The Salmas and the Salims also need to speak up. Violence is not a solution.

When there is an India Pakistan match, I have many a time seen Pakistani flags displayed for all to see in the Muslim dominated areas of Calcutta. Sorry but that does not endear me. When I see a Pakistani flag in my country the first thing I want tot ell those people that they should go to Pakistan and stay in India. This is not a question of Hindu - Muslim bias. If one was supporting Pakistan because they are a better team that's one thing, but blatantly supporting Pakistan because it is a Muslim country is bullshit. This is the kind of people that I get pissed with. Not someone like you and me who does not look at person's religion to assess them, but the kind of person he/ she is.